Bang for your ehealth buck

by Charles Wright on May 16, 2012

There are some statistics that are so photogenic that politicians cannot resist throwing them about, time after time, and sure enough, when Health Minister Tanya Plibersek told the CEDA conference today that ehealth would give Australia a great bang for its buck, she gave another workout to some figures that her predecessor, Nicola Roxon, used just a year or so ago.

The figures concern the number of hospital admissions that are medication related. According to Plibersek, the number comes to about 190,000 per year, or two to three per cent of the total admissions each year. That, she said, costs $660 million per year, which alone represents not that much less than will have been spent on the PCEHR over four years. According to the minister/s about 15,000 are due to inadequate patient information. For patients over 75, up to 30 per cent of admissions are known to be medication-related, with up to three quarters of these potentially preventable.

She used as an example a story she’d recently heard about an elderly man who collapsed in a shopping centre from “a perfectly preventable interaction between medicines”. She said that the incident occurred after the man’s GP and his specialist changed his medication independently of each other — without knowing what the other had done.

The figures she referred to come from a study by Libby Roughead, an associate professor and Dr Susan Semple, a research fellow, at South Australia’s School of Pharmacy and Medical Studies. Having already  written about them, and had the ministerial application of these figures described by Keith Heale as “either ignorance or wilful misrepresentation”, I thought I’d make some enquiries at the source, so I rang Libby Roughead in Adelaide.

I’m sure the minister will be delighted to learn that according to Roughead, electronic health records “absolutely should help us address that problem”.

And she says that EHRs are also likely to be invaluable in helping with another problem: the use of drugs when patients are released from hospital. She says that one study indicated that for every two people discharged, at least one has a missing script. And while she doesn’t have figures for this, she says that the opposite is also true: patients are being discharged with drugs that they should no longer be using.

In fact, according to her, ehealth records will become even more critical as increasing numbers of allied health practitioners start prescribing.

I don’t know if some of the other figures Plibersek used are old hat, but I found the fact that  “in any week, one in three Australian GPs see a patient for whom they have no current information” and more than one in five GPs face that situation every day very interesting.

She also used some figures on the duplication of tests. One study, mentioned in the journal of Clinical Pathology, indicated more than 7% of all tests ordered in a hospital’s immunology lab were unnecessary duplicates.

The speech indicated increasing awareness within government of the importance of ehealth apps.

“If we can partner with industry to create the right environment,” she told the conference, “eHealth has the potential to act as an innovation hub for app designers. And I trust if we get it right, that many talented designers out there will create new, revolutionary eHealth apps.”

{ 0 comments }

A tale of eHealth knights and dragons

by Charles Wright on May 15, 2012

Whenever life gets you down – when you’ve got the flu and laryngitis for instance – there’s nothing better than popping into bed with an inspiring book or article, and re-setting your emotional defaults.

For me, the Pharmacy Guild’s national chairman, Kos Sclavos, does it every time.  Somehow, Kos conjures up an age when knights of old (pharmacists) did battle with dragons (doctors) and won the hands of fair ladies … Julia Gillard’s? Tanya Plibersek’s?

The way Kos sees it, and he never seems to tire of telling us, doctors have been undermining confidence in the PCEHR because they want to control it.  Pharmacists, on the other hand, are a concerned and generous group of professionals who want to link benefits like electronic prescriptions to the PCEHR, and are dying to assist the average person in embracing the national ehealth record system.

In this month’s Pharmacy Journal of Australia, Kos returns to the theme, declaring that the guild’s MedView initiative – “connecting the pieces of my medications puzzle” – may be “the critical element that engages both consumers and health professionals”.

He says that if the PCEHR is going to be “more than just a registration system from July 1″, MedView will “need to be promoted widely to the Australian public”.

He describes MedView as a national ehealth initiative designed to improve patient health outcomes by giving healthcare providers the ability to view a combined record of a patient’s medications history.

“For the first time, MedView will provide a combined record of prescribed and dispensed medications for patients across community, hospital and aged care settings. Whether a patient is going in for day surgery, visiting a new specialist, or having a regular checkup, this information will allow prescribers to see a snapshot of current medicines and, importantly, will give an accurate indication of adherence to medications.”

I think I want one. Well, perhaps I don’t want one that gives my GP an accurate indication of adherence to medications. Could I have one instead that gives them a slightly inaccurate view? You know how they can go on about one’s forgetting to take the daily dose every now and again.

At any rate, MedView, says Kos, is “strictly for use by consent only”.

“Patients who give permission will have their records stored securely in a national repository, from which healthcare professionals to whom the patient has given consent will be able to access the information from their existing desktop software.”

What is fascinating to me is the way a knight like Kos seems to do a lot of socialising with dragons, err, GPs.

“Many doctors,” he writes, “have expressed their concerns to me regarding patients who do not opt into the PCEHR and, thus, MedView.”

Even more fascinating, these GPs have apparently told Kos that they are considering not prescribing controlled drugs to these patients. “As health professionals, they feel they are obliged to see full medication and prescribed history before they can make clinical judgments on the appropriateness of continuing therapy for controlled medicines. MedView will allow health professionals to see how many different prescribers of medications the patient has and the recent history using various drop-down fields. A doctor will be able to select information from the previous week or 90 days;  and there is enormous flexibility in the reporting functionality of MedView.”

Seems a bit drastic, doesn’t it? Are doctors really going to insist that their patients sign up the PCEHR and MedView, or risk not being able to receive prescriptions? Anyway, that’s what Kos says, and right now, I’m prepared to suspend my disbelief. The tale is too absorbing to want to spoil it with doubts and demurrals.

{ 0 comments }

eHealth dreams

May 14, 2012

The fact that I had to sit in my GP’s waiting room for 50 minutes this morning listening to other patients making the most awful hacking noises, to say nothing of the 12-year-old boy pleading for his life in one of the consulting rooms (injections don’t really hurt that much, do they?) has probably made [...]

Read the full article →

New vision for healthcare

May 11, 2012

I know I should have stayed tucked up in bed, but this article in The Guardian by European Commission vice-president Neelie Kroes, about a new vision for healthcare in Europe got me thinking. Kroes suggests that the key to financially viable healthcare systems lies more with “new approaches for telemonitoring, electronic prescriptions, and applications that [...]

Read the full article →

Silenced (temporarily)

May 11, 2012

My flu has unfortunately worsened and I now can hardly speak. I hope to be back on board next week. In the meantime, back to bed.

Read the full article →

Credit where it’s due (and not due)

May 9, 2012

NEHTA CEO Peter Fleming’s statement to the organisation on the ehealth Budget funding has got me thinking about the need for proper acknowledgment of outstanding achievement in the public interest. What he said was this: “This funding will allow NEHTA to continue its important work to build and support the rollout of the eHealth agenda. [...]

Read the full article →

iSoft plot outlined in court

May 8, 2012

The evidence being led in central London’s Southwark Crown Court in relation to charges against three former iSoft executives (a fourth, founder and then-chief executive Patrick Cryne is not in court because of ill health) makes fascinating reading. According to Strand News court reporting agency, whose report is carried in eHealth Insider, Cryne and his co-accused, [...]

Read the full article →

eHealth zero hour approaching

May 7, 2012

With just a little more than 24 hours to go before we learn how ehealth will fare in the Federal Budget, I’ve been talking to software vendors working on the PCEHR about their views. It seems they are mostly quietly confident that there is not going to be a dramatic cessation of funding. “We are [...]

Read the full article →

GPs and their computers: charming and inspiring

May 3, 2012

A battle-scarred hack like me tends not to wear his heart on his sleeve, but I admit to being completely charmed by Kathryn Eccles’ piece in Medical Observer in which three generations of GPs working at Sydney’s Cremorne Medical Practice – not far from where Joe Hockey’s GP is still presumably doing everything with pen [...]

Read the full article →

EHRs: the patient as resource

May 1, 2012

Buried in this story from the UK’s eHealth Insider on the fact that the NHS Information Centre is to collect data on which GP practices are offering patients access to their medical records online – the consequence of a promise by Chancellor George Osborne that by 2015, everybody in England will have online access to [...]

Read the full article →